[PAGE 1] AGENDA Board of Adjustments Meeting 7 p.m. - Monday, November 4, 2019 TOWN HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 127 N. COLLINS RD. Page A. Call Meeting To Order Chairperson calls the meeting to order, state the date and time. State members present and declare a quorum present. 3 - 5 1. Approval of minutes for the 10/7/19 Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting. MBOA 10.7.19 B. Public Hearing Open or continue public hearing, consider testimony and other information provided, close public hearing, and take necessary action with respect to the following: 6 - 12 2. Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by Dallas Wottlin for variances from Section 3.05 Zoning Dimensional Regulations of the Unified Development Ordinance, specifically Section 3.05.03 Residential Zoning District Dimensional Regulations Chart, to reduce the required lot size, width, front and side setback for a SF-3, Single Family zoned lot for proposed subdivision. Agenda Item Report - AIR-19-082 - Pdf C. Adjourn All locations identified are in the Town of Sunnyvale unless otherwise indicated. For a detailed property description, please contact the Building Official at Town Hall. All items on the agenda are for possible discussion and action. Please turn off all telephones and handheld communication devices while in attendance at this meeting. The Sunnyvale Board of Adjustment reserves the right to adjourn into executive session at any time during the course of this meeting to discuss any of the matters listed above, as authorized by Texas Government Code Section 551.071 (Consultation with Attorney), 551.072 (Deliberation about Real Property), 551.073 (Deliberations about Gifts and Donations), 551.074 (Personnel Matters), 551.076 Page 1 of 12 [PAGE 2] (Deliberations about Security Devices), and 551.087 (Economic Development). The Town of Sunnyvale is committed to compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Reasonable accommodations and equal access to communications will be provided to those who provide notice to the Director of Development Services at (972)226–7177 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. Notice of Possible Quorum of Town Council A quorum of the Town Council may be in attendance. This is not a regularly scheduled meeting of the Town Council. As a governmental body, the Town Council will not deliberate nor take any formal action on any items discussed. I hereby certify that the foregoing notice was posted by November 1, 2019, in the following location and remained so posted continuously for at least 72 hours preceding the scheduled time of said meeting: Town Hall at 127 N. Collins Road _____________________________________________ Rachel Ramsey, Town Secretary Page 2 of 12 [PAGE 3] MINUTES TOWN OF SUNNYVALE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS TOWN HALL CHAMBERS OCTOBER 7, 2019 7:00 P.M. CHAIRPERSON KAREN HILL - ABSENT MEMBER LYNDON JAMES MEMBER KEN DEMKO MEMBER JOE TURNER MEMBER DEE BLACKWOOD ALTERNATE MEMBER ROBERT WHITE ALTERNATE MEMBER SOJI JOHN - ABSENT CALL MEETING TO ORDER Member James called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. He served as Acting Chair for the meeting. 1. CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FOR THE MEETING OF JUNE 3, 2019. Member Blackwood made a motion to approve the minutes, seconded by Member White. Acting Chair James called for a vote and with all members voting affirmatively, the motion passed 5 / 0. 2. Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by the Arlyn Samuelson – Westwood Professional Services for variances from Section 3.05 Zoning Dimensional Regulations of the Unified Development Ordinance, specifically Section 3.05.04 Nonresidential and Special Zoning District Dimensional Regulations Chart, to reduce the required lot size, width, depth, and side setback for a GB, General Business zoned lot for proposed subdivision. Director of Development Services, Rashad Jackson, presented the request. The property was originally designed and received site plan approval in 2006 as a retail center on one lot. Phase I included the existing building on the subject property as well as the building directly to the rear which were both constructed the following year. Phase II included the existing building foundations directly abutting to the northeast which were never constructed upon. In 2016, the overall property was replatted into three lots so that they could be individually sold. At that time access was provided to all lots via a mutual access easement shown on the plat. The easement serves as a 24’ fire lane, access and utility easement. However, access is also given to all lots via a separately recorded reciprocal ingress egress easement running from the entrance drive on Collins Road along the northeast property lines and around the development to the rear along the southeast property lines. 1 Page 3 of 12 [PAGE 4] October 7, 2019 The current applicant is requesting a number of variances that are needed to be able to subdivide Lot 3R into two. Once the lot is created for the vacant building foundation it will then be sold to a separate owner for future development, however, the fire lane and reciprocal ingress egress easement will remain in place. If the process continues as explained the resulting development will essentially be no different than if developed as originally designed on one lot. The future building will be constructed on the existing pad site and have roughly the same footprint as originally intended. The following variances are being request for Lot 3R to be subdivided into two: 1. Variance of 49.12’ and 3.11’ to the required minimum lot width of 250’ (currently 200.88’ and 246.89’) 2. Variance of 62’ for each lot to the required minimum lot depth of 250’ (currently 188’ for each lot) 3. Variance of 49,355 sq.ft. and 40,705 sq.ft. to the required minimum lot size of 87,120 sq.ft. or 2 acres (currently 37,765 sq.ft. and 46,415 sq.ft.) 4. Variance of approximately 16’ for each lot’s interior side yard to the required minimum side yard setback of 25’ (currently approximately 9’ for each lot) Public Hearing – Open Applicant Arlyn Samuelson spoke on behalf of the request. He noted he was the civil engineer working for the property owner. He provided background. Chris Lovell, of Legacy Alliance Development, also spoke on behalf of the request. He noted his team was the potential buyer of the property. Member White asked where the applicant was in the sale process. Mr. Lovell noted the replat/variance was required as part of their purchase. He noted there was a contract in escrow. Public Hearing – Closed Discussion was had amongst the board and Director Jackson regarding development of the proposed lot. (Lot 3R) They discussed similar issues like the matter at hand throughout Town as well. Member Demko ask about the access point for the abutting property. He noted the access was closed off. Director Jackson explained the access would be constructed by the abutting property owner (Chic-fil-a). He noted access for the abutting property is currently available at the rear of the property. He noted a contractor for the Long Creek Crossing development likely closed the temporary access drive near Collins (352) once they were complete. Member Demko made a motion to approve as requested, seconded by Member Turner. Acting Chair James called for a vote and with all members voting affirmatively, the motion passed 5 / 0. ADJOURN 2 Page 4 of 12 [PAGE 5] October 7, 2019 Acting Chair James adjourned the meeting at 7:16 p.m. The undersigned presiding officer certifies that this is a true and correct record of the proceedings. ___________________________ for Chairperson Karen Hill ATTEST: ____________________________ Rachel Ramsey, Town Secretary 3 Page 5 of 12 [PAGE 6] Board of Adjustments AGENDA ITEM REPORT AIR-19-082 To: Board of Adjustment Subject: Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by Dallas Wottlin for variances from Section 3.05 Zoning Dimensional Regulations of the Unified Development Ordinance, specifically Section 3.05.03 Residential Zoning District Dimensional Regulations Chart, to reduce the required lot size, width, front and side setback for a SF-3, Single Family zoned lot for proposed subdivision. Meeting: Board of Adjustments - 04 Nov 2019 Department: Development Services Staff Contact: Rashad Jackson, Director of Development Services STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the requested variances to reduce the required lot size, lot width, and setbacks for 360 Michael Lane. Although not a hardship, staff finds the proposed request would allow for a better lot configuration that is more in line with the development intent for the area. BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The current applicant is requesting a number of variances that are needed to be able to subdivide the noted parcels (360 Michael Lane) into two. The non-conforming parcels that comprise 360 Michael Lane currently are un-platted. The property owner would like to revise the parcel configurations to create a more conforming lot configuration. The applicant intends to sell proposed lot #2 if the variance and subsequent plat are approved. The existing configuration of existing structures and existing lot dimensions would remain. Due to the proposed subdivision, proposed Lot #1 would require a side and front yard setback variance for the existing home. Lot #1 would also need a variance for the existing lot width. Proposed lot #2 would need a variance for the existing lot width and proposed lot size (0.94 acres). The setbacks for lot #2 would abide by the current requirement for a SF-3 lot. Possible Flag Lot Configuration If a variance is granted, proposed Lot #1 could be considered a flag lot. The proposed configuration, although possibly a flag configuration, would be considered a better conforming configuration for proper development of the subject area. The existing three parcel configuration of the property is not appropriate for development. The following variances are being request for the subject property to be subdivided into two: Proposed Lot #1 1. Variance of 70’ to the required minimum lot width of 170’ (currently 100’) Page 6 of 12 [PAGE 7] 2. Variance of approximately 15’ for a side setback (currently 15’) 3. Variance of 35’ for a front yard setback (currently 35’) Proposed Lot #2 1. Variance of 70’ to the required minimum lot width of 170’ (currently 100’) 2. Variance of approx 2,613 sq.ft. to the required minimum lot size of 43,560 sq.ft. or 1 acre (currently 40,946 sq.ft.) The variances are shown visually below. Zoning Ordinance – Variance Standards The following factors are to be taken into consideration when reviewing a variance request: 1. Unique Circumstances Page 2 of 7 Page 7 of 12 [PAGE 8] That there are special circumstances or conditions affecting the land involved such that the application of the provisions of Section 3 Zoning Regulations would deprive the applicant of the reasonable use of his/her land. 2. Minimum Necessary Relief Required to Alleviate the Undue Hardship That the zoning variance, if granted, would be the minimum necessary relief required to alleviate the undue hardship. 3. Preservation of Property Rights That the zoning variance is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right of the applicant. 4. No Substantial Detriment to the Public Good That the granting of the zoning variance will not be detrimental to the public health, safety or welfare, impair the purposes and intent of these Section 3 Zoning Regulations and the Comprehensive Plan or be injurious to other property within the area. 5. Orderly Use of Land That the granting of the zoning variance will not have the effect of preventing the orderly use of other land within the area in accordance with the provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance regulations. 6. Precedent That the granting of an individual zoning variance will not set a precedent. 7. Finding of Undue Hardship That an undue hardship exists, using the following criteria: a. That literal enforcement of the controls will create an undue hardship or practical difficulty in the development of the affected property; and b. That the situation causing the hardship or difficulty is neither self-imposed nor generally affecting all or most properties in the same zoning district; and c. That the relief sought will not injure the permitted use of adjacent conforming property; and d. That the granting of a zoning variance will be in harmony with the spirit and purpose of these regulations. e. Financial hardship alone is not an “undue hardship” if the property can be used, meeting the requirements of the zoning district in which the property is located. PUBLIC NOTICE: Page 3 of 7 Page 8 of 12 [PAGE 9] Notice was published within the Town’s Official Newspaper on Wednesday, October 16, 2019. Letters were also provided to surrounding properties meeting the distance requirements as provided within the Ordinance. As of the writing of this staff memo, the following letters had been received. In Favor – 0 In Opposition - 0 ATTACHMENTS: Map Existing Configuration Variance_Plans Page 4 of 7 Page 9 of 12 [PAGE 10] TOWN OF SUNNYVALE 360 Michael Lane - Proposed Lot Dimension Variances 307 225 303 348 223 223 223 350 353 357 359 361 361 365 221 MICHAEL LN 217 352 354 356 358 360 362 360 215 C O L L 1300 354 213 IN 360 S 213 351 357 401 240 250 216 353 TRIPP RD 363 365 402 404 406 361 355 441100 295 148 402 381 Legend 391 TRIPP Buf1fe40r Notice Area 368 337700 370 F 0 110 220 440 Feet Page 5 of 7 Page 10 of 12 [PAGE 11] Page 6 of 7Page 11 of 12 [PAGE 12] (LOT #1) Does not meet the following requirements: -minimum lot width of 170 feet (actual 100 feet) -minimum front yard setback of 70 feet -minimum side yard setback of 30 feet We’d like a variance for the above dimensional requirements. (LOT #2) Does not meet the following requiremnts: -minimum lot width of 170 feet -minimum lot area of 1 acre We’d like a variance for the above dimensional requirements. Page 7 of 7 Page 12 of 12