[PAGE 1] AGENDA Board of Adjustments Meeting 7 p.m. - Monday, October 7, 2019 TOWN HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS 127 N. COLLINS RD. Page A. Call Meeting To Order Chairperson calls the meeting to order, state the date and time. State members present and declare a quorum present. B. Discussion/Action Items 3 - 4 1. Approval of minutes for the 6/3/2019 Board of Adjustments Regular Meeting. MBOA 6.3.19 C. Public Hearing Open or continue public hearing, consider testimony and other information provided, close public hearing, and take necessary action with respect to the following: 5 - 11 2. Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by the Arlyn Samuelson – Westwood Professional Services for variances from Section 3.05 Zoning Dimensional Regulations of the Unified Development Ordinance, specifically Section 3.05.04 Nonresidential and Special Zoning District Dimensional Regulations Chart, to reduce the required lot size, width, depth, and side setback for a GB, General Business zoned lot for proposed subdivision. Agenda Item Report - AIR-19-046 - Pdf D. Adjourn All locations identified are in the Town of Sunnyvale unless otherwise indicated. For a detailed property description, please contact the Building Official at Town Hall. All items on the agenda are for possible discussion and action. Please turn off all telephones and handheld communication devices while in attendance at this meeting. The Sunnyvale Town Council reserves the right to adjourn into executive session at any time during the course of this meeting to Page 1 of 11 [PAGE 2] discuss any of the matters listed above, as authorized by Texas Government Code Section 551.071 (Consultation with Attorney), 551.072 (Deliberation about Real Property), 551.073 (Deliberations about Gifts and Donations), 551.074 (Personnel Matters), 551.076 (Deliberations about Security Devices), and 551.087 (Economic Development). The Town of Sunnyvale is committed to compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Reasonable accommodations and equal access to communications will be provided to those who provide notice to the Director of Development Services at (972)226–7177 at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. Notice of Possible Quorum of Town Council A quorum of the Town Council may be in attendance. This is not a regularly scheduled meeting of the Town Council. As a governmental body, the Town Council will not deliberate nor take any formal action on any items discussed. I hereby certify that the foregoing notice was posted by October 4, 2019, in the following location and remained so posted continuously for at least 72 hours preceding the scheduled time of said meeting: Town Hall at 127 N. Collins Road _____________________________________________ Rachel Ramsey, Town Secretary Page 2 of 11 [PAGE 3] MINUTES TOWN OF SUNNYVALE BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS TOWN HALL CHAMBERS JUNE 3, 2019 7:00 P.M. CHAIRPERSON KAREN HILL MEMBER LYNDON JAMES MEMBER JEAN HOLT – ABSENT MEMBER JACK KIRKLAND MEMBER DEE BLACKWOOD ALTERNATE MEMBER ROBERT WHITE ALTERNATE MEMBER SOJI JOHN CALL MEETING TO ORDER Chairperson Hill called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. 1. CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES FOR THE MEETING OF MAY 6, 2019. Member Blackwood made a motion to approve the minutes, seconded by Member James. Chairperson Hill called for a vote and with all members voting affirmatively, the motion passed 4 / 0. 2. Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by the Town of Sunnyvale to initiate proceedings for abatement of an unsafe structure by demolition at or about 457 Stone Canyon Drive. Building Official, Doug Key, presented the request. This request came before the Board of Adjustments at the May 6, 2019 regularly scheduled meeting. At that meeting a motion was passed to table the item for a period of 30 days to allow the owner to complete the following items: 1. Obtain a report from a structural engineer concerning the current state of the partially constructed home. 2. Obtain financing to complete construction of the home. The Building Official stated that as of the previous Friday the property had been sold and the new owners that were present at the meeting had no knowledge until the day of the meeting that the above items were required. He went on to read a printed email from the previous owner. *** Member White arrives at approximately 7:05 p.m. Chairperson Hill opened the public hearing. Michael Cervantes, contractor for the project residing at 1701 W. Main Street, Lancaster, spoke and answered questions from the Board. 1 Page 3 of 11 [PAGE 4] June 3, 2019 Chairperson Hill asked if anyone would like to make a motion to dismiss the action of demolition of the structure at 457 Stone Canyon and allow construction to resume contingent to the following: 1. Letter from a structural engineer be included with the new construction permit stating the viability of the partially constructed home. 2. Construction to be complete within 90 days (with the possibility of an extension to 120 days by the Building Official). Member James made a motion to dismiss the action of demolition and allow construction to resume contingent to the above items, seconded by Member Blackwood. Chairperson Hill called for a vote and with all members voting affirmatively, the motion passed 4 / 0. ADJOURN Chairperson Hill adjourned the meeting at 7:15 p.m. The undersigned presiding officer certifies that this is a true and correct record of the proceedings. ___________________________ Chairperson Karen Hill ATTEST: ____________________________ Rachel Ramsey, Town Secretary 2 Page 4 of 11 [PAGE 5] Board of Adjustments AGENDA ITEM REPORT AIR-19-046 To: Board of Adjustments Subject: Hold a public hearing to discuss, consider, and act upon a request by the Arlyn Samuelson – Westwood Professional Services for variances from Section 3.05 Zoning Dimensional Regulations of the Unified Development Ordinance, specifically Section 3.05.04 Nonresidential and Special Zoning District Dimensional Regulations Chart, to reduce the required lot size, width, depth, and side setback for a GB, General Business zoned lot for proposed subdivision. Meeting: Board of Adjustments - 07 Oct 2019 Department: Development Services Staff Contact: Erick del Angel, Town Planner STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of the requested variances to reduce the required lot size, width, depth, and side setback for 184 S. Collins Road. BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The property was originally designed and received site plan approval in 2006 as a retail center on one lot. Phase I included the existing building on the subject property as well as the building directly to the rear that were both constructed the following year. Phase II included the existing building foundations directly abutting to the northeast that were never constructed upon. In 2016, the overall property was replatted into three lots so that they could be individually sold. At that time access was provided to all lots via a mutual access easement shown on the plat. The easement serves as a 24’ fire lane, access and utility easement. However, access is also given to all lots via a separately recorded reciprocal ingress egress easement running from the entrance drive on Collins Road along the northeast property lines and around the development to the rear along the southeast property lines. The current applicant is requesting a number of variances that are needed to be able to subdivide Lot 3R into two. Once the lot is created for the vacant building foundation, it will then be sold to a separate owner for future development; However, the fire lane and reciprocal ingress egress easement will remain in place. If the process continues as explained, the resulting development will essentially be no different than if developed as originally designed on one lot. The future building will be constructed on the existing pad site and have roughly the same footprint as originally intended. The following variances are being request for Lot 3R to be subdivided into two: 1. Variance of 49.12’ and 3.11’ to the required minimum lot width of 250’ (currently 200.88’ and 246.89’) 2. Variance of 62’ for each lot to the required minimum lot depth of 250’ (currently 188’ for each lot) 3. Variance of 49,355 sq.ft. and 40,705 sq.ft. to the required minimum lot size of 87,120 sq.ft. or 2 acres (currently 37,765 sq.ft. and 46,415 sq.ft.) Page 5 of 11 [PAGE 6] 4. Variance of approximately 16’ for each lot’s interior side yard to the required minimum side yard setback of 25’ (currently approximately 9’ for each lot) Below is a graphic that depicts the requested variances. As stated earlier, the intent is for the eventual construction of a building that would be geometrically very similar if not identical to the existing one on Lot 3R. To move forward with the platting, sale, and development, the applicant has requested variances for the proposed lot dimensions. Zoning Ordinance – Variance Standards Chapter 26 Variance Procedures of the Zoning Ordinance establishes the standards for approval of a variance. The Board of Adjustments shall not approve a variance unless it finds that the variance is not contrary to the public interest and, due to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the ordinance would result in Page 2 of 7 Page 6 of 11 [PAGE 7] unnecessary hardship, and so that the spirit of the ordinance is observed and substantial justice is done. The following factors are to be taken into consideration when reviewing a variance request: 1. That there are special circumstances or conditions applicable to the property referred to in the application that does not prevail on other property in that zone. Most other nonresidential properties similar to the subject property were part of a planned development. These developments, like the property in question, were developed in phases, but were nonetheless completed within a few years while the subject property was never fully constructed and the original developer/owner has moved on. 2. That the strict application of the regulations would cause an unnecessary hardship and that the granting of the application is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of substantial existing property rights. Strict application of the regulations may cause unnecessary hardship to the applicant but it would not prevent construction of the building. It would only prevent division of the lot and restrict the subsequent sale of the property. 3. That the granting of such application will not materially affect the health and safety of persons residing or working in the neighborhood and will not be materially detrimental to the public welfare or injurious to property or improvements in the neighborhood. The granting of the variance does not appear to affect the health and safety of persons residing in the area nor does it appear to be detrimental to the public welfare. The property is surrounded by developed as well as developing nonresidential uses along a major commercial corridor; thus its impact would be very minimal to the surrounding area. 4. That substantial conformity to standards primarily established in the zone may be secured. With the exception of the requested variances, it would appear that all other zoning standards for GB, General Business district would be adhered to. 5. That detriment of injury to the neighborhood will not result from the granting of a variance as applied for. There does not appear to be detriment of injury to the neighborhood should the variances be granted. As stated earlier, the property is surrounded by nonresidential properties along a major commercial corridor. 6. That substantial conformity to standards previously established in the zone may be secured and that detriment of injury to the neighborhood will not result from the granting of a variance as applied for. Conformity to minimum lot width according to the previous zoning ordinance would be secured since only 200’ was required along arterials at that time. Other dimensional requirements would not conform; however, injury to the neighborhood will not result from the granting of the variances as applied for. PUBLIC NOTICE: Notice was published within the Town’s Official Newspaper on Wednesday, Sept. 19, 2019. Letters were also provided to surrounding properties meeting the distance requirements as provided within the Ordinance. Six (6) letters were sent out. As of the writing of this staff memo, the following letters had been received. In Favor – 0 In Opposition - 0 ATTACHMENTS: Site plan Location map Buffer map Site Pictures Page 3 of 7 Page 7 of 11 [PAGE 8] B.M. E V I R D N O PROPOSED LOT 3R1, BLOCK A ) PROPOSED LOT 3R2, BLOCK A SUNNYVALE COLLINS REATAIL . YW SUNNYVALE COLLINS REATAIL 46,415 SQUARE FEET N. O 37,765 SQUARE FEET 1.066 ACRES 0.867 ACRES A. R C '2 7 E( N O T S GWD.XEPS-6093200\LIVIC\GWD\ATAD TCEJORP 1\00.6093200\:N SHEET NUMBER: DESIGNED: PREPARED FOR: CHECKED: DRAWN: FIELD CREW: FIELD WORK DATE: DATE: .cnI ,secivreS lanoisseforP doowtseW 9102 © GRAPHIC SCALE 1"=30' 30 0 30 60 INITIAL ISSUE: REVISIONS: SUNNYVALE COLLINS RETAIL Phone (214) 473-4640 2740 Dallas Parkway, Suite 280 SITE EXHIBIT TFe rolel (888) 937-5150 Plano, TX 75093 . 4125 CENTURION WAY, SUITE 100 SUNNYVALE, TEXAS . ADDISON, TEXAS 75001 TBPE FIRM REGISTRATION NO. F-11756 08-06-2019 P0023906.00 LIATER SNILLOC ELAVYNNUS SUNNYVALE 08-06-2019 AWS RPP SE WTW LEGACY ALLIANCE Page 4 of 7 Page 8 of 11 [PAGE 9] TOWN OF SUNNYVALE Westwood Professional Services - Variances to Lot Dimensions 2 5 3 y w H F 0 40 C 8 A 0S N T Y O N E 160 Legend FeDe R t O N Subject Property Page 5 of 7 Page 9 of 11 [PAGE 10] TOWN OF SUNNYVALE Westwood Professional Services - Variances to Lot Dimensions 2 5 3 y w H S A N G A B R IE L S TO N E R A C N A C N H Y E O R N O D D R R F 0 95 190 380 Legend Feet Subject Property Properties within 200' Page 6 of 7 Page 10 of 11 [PAGE 11] SITE PICTURES Figure 4: View from subject property facing west Figure 3: View from subject property facing south Figure 2: View from subject property facing north Figure 1: View from subject property facing east Page 7 of 7 Page 11 of 11